Are Positive Changes in Police Response to Domestic Violence Limited by Victim Reluctance to Involve Law Enforcement?
Historically there has been a real reticence to call in law enforcement personnel on the part of both men and women who are victims of domestic violence. This reluctance to call in legal assistance has been attributed to several factors, including embarrassment and fear. Whatever the reason, many victims today are no more willing to call and end the nightmare than they were 20 years ago.1
In 1967, the President's Crime Commission explored a victim's willingness to call the police and found that it was relatively low--about 25%--overall.
The most recent surveys completed by the National Crime Victimization Survey in 2008 relate that the willingness to call law enforcement has changed very little. This is despite the elapsed time and a wide range of improvements in law enforcement techniques and responses to domestic violence.2
The Minneapolis Domestic Violence Experiment, run in 1984 found that a police response to domestic violence significantly reduced the number of incidents. A single arrest in a domestic violence case lowered the chances of future violence in the family by as much as half. This was the first controlled testing on the effects of arrest on any type of criminal activity. Arresting the perpetrator of domestic violence was found to be the single biggest deterrent to future violence.
In response to this testing, new domestic violence programs and police training were implemented in multiple police departments around the country. The result was that police departments responded more rapidly, investigated more fully and more perpetrators were arrested. The incidence of domestic violence fell about 15 percent in a relatively short amount of time.
As police departments across the United States and abroad move to address the pandemic that domestic violence has become, more and more resources become available to the men and women who are victimized by domestic violence.3
Reaction times are down significantly in domestic violence calls, with police arriving on scene far more rapidly. Even simple assaults are being prosecuted effectively and counseling offered to families in crisis. A more full set of resources are being offered by the police departments attending the domestic abuse calls. Special considerations such as female officers are offered to attend to those women who are victims of domestic violence. Police are trained to remove one partner from the home and in many cases can recommend and arrange shelter for the displaced partner as part of the police response to domestic violence.4
A vast number of new shelters have opened, giving more women and children protection and respite from a violent home situation.
Despite all of these changes, it appears that victims of domestic violence and woman in particular are nearly as unwilling to call in law enforcement today as they were in the mid-1960s.
With so many favorable changes in the laws that protect both men and women from domestic violence, it remains to be seen why more women do not call law enforcement personnel when a domestic violence incident takes place. Further education and public relations of the various police departments may be helpful in bringing domestic violence victims closer to making the phone call that they need to make to guarantee their own safety.
The laws have changed. The response of law enforcement has changed. Your world can change too. If you are a victim of domestic violence---Make the call.
1. Why women stay: A theoretical examination of rational choice and moral reasoning in the context of intimate partner violence Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology (2012) 45 (2): 179-193 http://anj.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/45/2/179
2. Righting Domestic Violence Int J Law Policy Family (2006) 20 (1): 95-119 http://lawfam.oxfordjournals.org/content/20/1/95.full.pdf+html
3. Victim Experiences and Perspectives on Police Responses to Verbal Violence in Domestic Settings Feminist Criminology (2013) 8 (4): 269-294 http://spfcx.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/8/4/269
4. The Impact of Victim-Focused Outreach on Criminal Legal System Outcomes Following Police-Reported Intimate Partner Abuse Violence Against Women (2012) 18 (8): 861-881 http://vaw.sagepub.com/cgi/content/full/18/8/861
5. Police release with conditions of the accused in cases of domestic violence in Montreal, Canada Criminal Justice (2009) 9 (1): 51-71 http://crj.sagepub.com/cgi/reprint/9/1/51
6. Abused Women's Perspectives on the Criminal Justice System's Response to Domestic Violence Psychology of Women Quarterly (2007) 31 (2): 202-215 http://pwq.sagepub.com/content/31/2/202.full.pdf+html
7. United States v. Morrison, 529 US 598 - Supreme Court 2000 (Opinion) Discusses congress role in instituting laws concerning domestic violence and separation of powers between the federal government and states. States are primarily responsible for the police response to domestic violence because of the U.S. Constitution's reservation of police powers in the states.
8. United States v. Morrison, 529 US 598 - Supreme Court 2000 (Souter Dissent) Justice Souter dissents about the role of congress in passing laws to help against domestic violence through civil penalties because of the huge impact that domestic violence has on interstate commerce. Souter's dissent lists a vast amount of evidence produced in showing the high cost of such violence.
Return from Police Response to Domestic Violence to the Domestic Violence Help homepage.